Question about grade, valuation and authenticity

6 mensajes

Este tema se publicó en el foro en inglés.

Im having worries about couple of those coins, the 1788 duit and the French coin from 1635

those coins are maybe those

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces52650.html

About that French coin,I'm wondering if that is the exact type, also how.should I grade that coin, patina, I can't see good VG,F,VF, What do you think?

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces37440.html

About that one is complicated,my coin weighs 3.04grams, the one from the link is 3.84, I found different variations, some of them with the weight of mine, but with different design
Is it possible to have fake coin?

See photos below
​​​








Kristian

Everything in my collection can be sold if it would make someone happier than me :)
All of these coins, including the ones you have worry about, are perfectly authentic.
Cita: "Choucas"​All of these coins, including the ones you have worry about, are perfectly authentic.
​Thank you for relaxing my thoughts.
how about grading and valuation, also I am not sure if the coins from the photos are the same from the links? I'm asking only about those 2

https://fr.numista.com/forum/images/5d90c09a68075.jpg
https://fr.numista.com/forum/images/5d90c0b512cfa.jpg
https://fr.numista.com/forum/images/5d90c0cc34d86.jpg
https://fr.numista.com/forum/images/5d90c0e15cf97.jpg
Kristian

Everything in my collection can be sold if it would make someone happier than me :)
Personally, I would grade the 1635 French coin about G+, because the date and some of the writing is legible, but not all, and overall the coin is in rough shape. For the 1788 duit, again personally, I would grade it F+. The dated side I would give a VF, the other side F, so averaging about F+. Of course others may have differing opinions, and grading depends to some degree on how well struck the original coins of that type were.
Cita: "Seeker55"​Personally, I would grade the 1635 French coin about G+, because the date and some of the writing is legible, but not all, and overall the coin is in rough shape. For the 1788 duit, again personally, I would grade it F+. The dated side I would give a VF, the other side F, so averaging about F+. Of course others may have differing opinions, and grading depends to some degree on how well struck the original coins of that type were.
​how about price(+-) for those 2, or for all because I will probably take all
Kristian

Everything in my collection can be sold if it would make someone happier than me :)
It looks like the 1788 duit in F+ has a book value of about $5-6.

https://www.ngccoin.com/price-guide/world/netherlands-gelderland-duit-km-108-1788-1794-cuid-1112245-duid-1433470

The French 1635 double tournois of Louis XIII I don't find listed in NGC, but in my older edition (1999) of 17th century Krause's world coins this type of coin looks like it lists for about $6-10 in VG condition, depending on mint. (I would add some for time elapsed since then, subtract some for G+ compared to VG, so this is still a ballpark figure).

It should also be kept in mind that coins often sell for less than book value.
I don't see any reason to question the authenticity of these coins.

» Política del foro

La zona horaria usada es UTC+2:00.
La hora actual es 12:18.