Asian Coins ID Please!

18 mensajes

Este tema se publicó en el foro en inglés.

» Acceso rápido al último mensaje

AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 15:37 #
Publicado: #
PetrusAscanus
Registrado: 22 nov 2014
Mensajes: 6304
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 17:20 #
Publicado: #
2 and 3 look like chinese cash
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/chine_empire-1.html
3 looks like replica
Non est totum quod splendet ut aurum
Rijkdom bestaat niet uit het hebben van veel bezittingen, maar in het hebben van weinig behoeften
Frenchlover Revisor/a del catálogo
Registrado: 16 jul 2013
Mensajes: 13619
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 18:36 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "PetrusAscanus"​3 looks like replica

you promised not to tell it again :D


​De Zong - Boo Guang DH#22.1336
Referee of south atlantic islands
PetrusAscanus
Registrado: 22 nov 2014
Mensajes: 6304
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 18:56 #
Publicado: #
Sorry, I take it back that I think it is a replica x.
Non est totum quod splendet ut aurum
Rijkdom bestaat niet uit het hebben van veel bezittingen, maar in het hebben van weinig behoeften
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 21:52 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "Frenchlover"​
Cita: "PetrusAscanus"​3 looks like replica
​
​
​you promised not to tell it again :D
​
​
​​De Zong - Boo Guang DH#22.1336
​
​
​Thanks, which one exactly is it?
Frenchlover Revisor/a del catálogo
Registrado: 16 jul 2013
Mensajes: 13619
Publicado: 29 may 2016, 22:11 #
Publicado: #
the last one. You should add it in the catalog. It's an interesting coin: the end of casting
Referee of south atlantic islands
chomp-master
Registrado: 10 mar 2015
Mensajes: 5744
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 1:24 #
Publicado: #
More "the beginning of machine-striking" that way...

No need to add, it is already available.
https://fr.numista.com/catalogue/pieces22475.html
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 11:10 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "chomp-master"​More "the beginning of machine-striking" that way...
​
​No need to add, it is already available.
​https://fr.numista.com/catalogue/pieces22475.html
​Thank you!
Frenchlover Revisor/a del catálogo
Registrado: 16 jul 2013
Mensajes: 13619
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 13:22 #
Publicado: #
The first one is from Japan
The second from Ren Zong - Jiaqing 7th emp
probably Boo Je
Referee of south atlantic islands
chomp-master
Registrado: 10 mar 2015
Mensajes: 5744
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 14:02 #
Publicado: #
Turning back to the 2nd one, it seems highly damaged and this will make any ID very random. However in highlines this has high chances to be a Jiaqing coin whose name was hardly worn. Concerning the mintmark, I'm hesitating the same way (worn again) between Boo-jin and Boo-je.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 16:18 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "Frenchlover"​The first one is from Japan
​The second from Ren Zong - Jiaqing 7th emp
​probably Boo Je
​Thanks for the good info!
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 16:22 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "Frenchlover"​The first one is from Japan
​The second from Ren Zong - Jiaqing 7th emp
​probably Boo Je
​How do i know which year the first coin is?
chomp-master
Registrado: 10 mar 2015
Mensajes: 5744
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 16:26 #
Publicado: #
My opinion is the mintmarks should be added elsewhere on the coin. I don't see a mintmark, but maybe you may have a better view of these marks, especially on the plain side?
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 16:26 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "chomp-master"​Turning back to the 2nd one, it seems highly damaged and this will make any ID very random. However in highlines this has high chances to be a Jiaqing coin whose name was hardly worn. Concerning the mintmark, I'm hesitating the same way (worn again) between Boo-jin and Boo-je.
​The reverse marks don't seem to indicate either? Unless i'm being a fool.
chomp-master
Registrado: 10 mar 2015
Mensajes: 5744
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 16:30 #
Publicado: #
As I told you, me neither. So if not altered regarding the condition, this one is the 1st variety, with no mintmark.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
AngHol
Registrado: 16 feb 2016
Mensajes: 325
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 19:33 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "chomp-master"​As I told you, me neither. So if not altered regarding the condition, this one is the 1st variety, with no mintmark.
​Ok, thanks Chomp!
Frenchlover Revisor/a del catálogo
Registrado: 16 jul 2013
Mensajes: 13619
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 19:45 #
Publicado: #
Cita: "chomp-master"​Turning back to the 2nd one, it seems highly damaged and this will make any ID very random. However in highlines this has high chances to be a Jiaqing coin whose name was hardly worn. Concerning the mintmark, I'm hesitating the same way (worn again) between Boo-jin and Boo-je.
​Yes, Bo-jin might be a good alternative even though the mintmark is slightly different.
DH#22.532 with a small "ji" in "jia" lasted from 1799 to 1820, so there might be some variation in the mintmark ?
Referee of south atlantic islands
chomp-master
Registrado: 10 mar 2015
Mensajes: 5744
Publicado: 30 may 2016, 20:38 #
Publicado: #
Even that mintmark seems enough worn to made this ID incomplete in my own eyes.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Respuesta
Foro »

» Política del foro

La zona horaria usada es UTC+2:00.
La hora actual es 5:26.