MPCC II: Asian Final Finals

Sorry guys, but there's a paradox the must be settled!



Burma - 1 Kyat - Mindon Min



VS

Japan - 5 Sen - Showa



VS

Japan - 50 Sen - Meiji

#3.

#2

I don't think this needs to be settled.  The coin that won the proper finals should be the one to take it out.

I agree with Neil. It's getting a but silly now

Cita: neilithicI don't think this needs to be settled.  The coin that won the proper finals should be the one to take it out.

To some extent. But winners are winners. Besides, does voting take more than 30 seconds of your time?

In that case I vote for the winner of the previous final.

I think it was number 1

But personally I don't think you should run this.  The Burmese coin got through to the finals fair and square and beat the coin that was supposed to be put up against it.  Personally I only voted for the 50 sen in the finals because I thought it was mine.  If you run this and the coin ends up losing then the owner of the Burma coin would be well within their rights to be feela  bit cheated.

It's like in tennis.  Nadal usually beats Federer, Djokovic usually beats Nadal and Federer usually beats Djokovic, but whoever gets into the finals are the ones who count.  If Federer loses in the semis to Nadal and then Djokovic beats Nadal in the Final Federer doesn't really have a right to claim victory by saying he usually beats Djokovic.

Coin 1, the winner.

I honestly don't care.

But it was a weird vote though... the fact that this recount was delayed until now is, like what Neil said, a little silly, but if it was done at the time like this, it would make sense.

#2 for this one. #3 isn't that great, it's just a half-dollar sized silver coin, and #1 is a giant peacock; it's cool, but not as well designed as #2.

Bored.

I can see where Neil is coming from and he is probably correct, if you want to keep the voting coins, just start planning MPCC III

Although #1 and #2 were tied, I will allow #1 to win because it won before (and I am only human, so my counting may not have been correct, but people seemed to like #1).

#1 Amazing coin

Cita: elvis123#1 Amazing coin

Well you settled it!