Merging of pages

5 mensajes • visto 95 veces

Este tema se publicó en el foro en inglés.

Este mensaje tiene como objetivo: solicitar la modificación de una moneda en el catálogo

Estado: Rechazado
Votos a favor: 2
Votos en contra: 1

N#76480
N#63934
 

Seems like these two coins are doubles. They are from the same material and size, just two different mints. We could merge them into one and add different mint marks for the years.

 

Same with these two:

N#90956

N#63931


And these as well:

N#23996

N#95155


Also the same is with a lot of those Russian coins, from ~1750 to ~1860

 

Should we merge each type into one page, because seemingly there is a single page for the mint mark variations, so we could just add them to the year lines. I could just add date lines to the one page to the other and delete the other page. I have time and could do that

 

Greetings

Anything here?

@Grinya   Do you have an opinion on this suggestion?  According to catalog guidelines, we could have one listing covering both mints unless there are other considerations (other design details that are different, etc.) to support keeping two listings.  

tdziemia

@Grinya   Do you have an opinion on this suggestion?  According to catalog guidelines, we could have one listing covering both mints unless there are other considerations (other design details that are different, etc.) to support keeping two listings.  

The tradition of separation Warsaw mint coins from coins minted on Russian mints came from Russian catalogues, possibly to allow collectors of Polish coins separate their interest from other. 

 

I guess that according to Numista logic it would be ok to merge them, but the logic of Russian part of the catalogue initially created with separation.

 

Personally for Warsaw coins I'm ok with both options. 

But as they was  initially created as separated, I like a current structure slightly more and don't see too much reasons to delete something created before:)

My personal list of scammers from Numista: erniemix, yvain, CassTaylor

Grinya

tdziemia

@Grinya   Do you have an opinion on this suggestion?  According to catalog guidelines, we could have one listing covering both mints unless there are other considerations (other design details that are different, etc.) to support keeping two listings.  

The tradition of separation Warsaw mint coins from coins minted on Russian mints came from Russian catalogues, possibly to allow collectors of Polish coins separate their interest from other. 

 

I guess that according to Numista logic it would be ok to merge them, but the logic of Russian part of the catalogue initially created with separation.

 

Personally for Warsaw coins I'm ok with both options. 

But as they was  initially created as separated, I like a current structure slightly more and don't see too much reasons to delete something created before:)

Okay, thanks! I didn’t know that so it’s of course fine to be left just how it is now

Estado cambiado a rechazado (tdziemia, 27 abr 2026, 17:03)

» Política del foro

La zona horaria usada es UTC+2:00.
La hora actual es 16:15.