Bukharan People's Soviet Republic 100r. Continuation of the preivous BPSR thread [resuelto]

Hi, a couple months ago we dicussed wether some banknotes of the BPSR should be merged or not. We didnt reach a concensus about the 100r, hence the new thread.

 If we follow the same path of giving each watermark/paper color diference an individual entry, like we did with the smaller denominations then we would have 5 different 100r ruble entries.
 

I think this is unecessary because this is a single issue (like the previous denominations), these are just varieties. There are many numista entries for banknotes that deal with these varieties the way they should be dealt with; just list them all in the varieties section. 

Before Bukhara i had been dealing with varieties in the aformentioned way, approved, with no issues. Bukhara wouldve been the same, but whoever wrote the  SCWPM (the catalogued used as bluprint for the creation of the russian civil war section) decided to split them, and they didnt even did it right. otherwise they wouldve listed 5 entries for 100r. 

In face of better and more accurate catalogues why are we still following the SCWPM? They didnt fully know or cared what they were doing regarding russian civil war, and it shows.

https://en.numista.com/232825
N#232816

Hello!

Yes, I remember your research and considerations regarding these issues. Well done, I might add.

Would your request be for these two pages to be unified? And would that include the other variants of this 100-ruble banknote in this page?

vladthiengo

Hello!

 

Yes, I remember your research and considerations regarding these issues. Well done, I might add.

 

Would your request be for these two pages to be unified? And would that include the other variants of this 100-ruble banknote in this page?

Hi, yes, unify them and then ill suggest a modification that lists all 5 varieties at the bottom.

Most of the remaning bukhara nots also have a bunch of varieties (even more than 5), i'll do the same and list them at the bottom when suggesting the modification.

Ideally, for concistency sake, i think merging 10 and 25 rubles would be a logical move , though i understand if mods consider its not worth it. 

I would settle for the merge of this 100r note (at a quick glance it appears the remaning notes arent duplicated, so no merging for those)

Thanks.